copyright 27.1 KB
Newer Older
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
1
Copyright (C) 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010  Free Software Foundation, Inc.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
2
See the end of the file for license conditions.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
3 4


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
NOTES ON COPYRIGHTS AND LICENSES

Some terminology:

A "copyright notice" consists of one or a few lines of this format:
"Copyright (C) 2006, 2007 Free Software Foundation, Inc."

A "license notice" is a statement of permissions, and is usually much
longer, eg the text "GNU Emacs is free software...".


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
16 17
Summary for the impatient:

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
18
1. Don't add code to Emacs written by someone other than yourself
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
without thinking about the legal aspect. Even if the changes are
trivial, consider if they combine with previous changes by the same
author to make a non-trivial total. If so, make sure they have an
assignment. If adding a whole file adjust the copyright statements in
the file.

2. When installing code written by someone else, the ChangeLog entry
should be in the name of the author of the code, not the person who
27 28 29
installs it.  I think it is helpful to put the author (if not yourself)
in the commit log as well (you can also use bzr commit's "--author"
option); and to not install any of your own changes in the same commit.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
30 31

3. With images, add the legal info to a README file in the directory
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
32 33
containing the image.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
34
4. If you add a lot of text to a previously trivial file that had no
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
35 36
legal notices, consider if you should add a copyright statement.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
37
5. Please don't just add an FSF copyright without checking that is the
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
38 39
right thing to do.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
40

41
Every non-trivial file distributed through the Emacs repository should be
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
42 43
self-explanatory in terms of copyright and license. This includes
files that are not distributed in Emacs releases (for example, the
44
admin/ directory), because the whole Emacs repository is publicly
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
45 46 47 48 49
available.

The definition of triviality is a little vague, but a rule of thumb is
that any file with less than 15 lines of actual content is trivial. If
a file is auto-generated (eg ldefs-boot.el) from another one in the
50 51
repository, then it does not really matter about adding a copyright
statement to the generated file.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
52

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60
Legal advice says that we could, if we wished, put a license notice
even in trivial files, because copyright law in general looks at the
overall work as a whole. It is not _necessary_ to do so, and rms
prefers that we do not. This means one needs to take care that trivial
files do not grow and become non-trivial without having a license
added. NB consequently, if you add a lot of text to a small file,
consider whether your changes have made the file worthy of a copyright
notice, and if so, please add one.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
61

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
62 63 64
It can be helpful to put a reminder comment at the start of a trivial
file, eg: "add a license notice if this grows to > 10 lines of code".

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
65
The years in the copyright notice should be updated every year (see
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
66
file "years" in this directory). The PDF versions of refcards etc
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
67 68 69
should display copyright notices (an exception to the rule about
"generated" files), but these can just display the latest year. The
full list of years should be kept in comments in the source file. If
70 71
these are distributed in the repository, check in a regenerated
version when the tex files are updated.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
72 73 74 75 76

Copyright changes should be propagated to any associated repositories
(eg Gnus, MH-E), but I think in every case this happens automatically
(?).

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
77 78
All README (and other such text files) that are non-trivial should
contain copyright statements and GPL license notices, exactly as .el
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
79
files do (see e.g. README in the top-level directory). Before 2007,
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
80 81
we used a simple, short statement permitting copying and modification
provided legal notices were retained. In Feb 2007 we switched to the
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
82 83
standard GPL text, on legal advice. Some older text files in etc/
should, however, keep their current licenses (see below for list).
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
84

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
85 86 87
For image files, the copyright and license details should be recorded
in a README file in each directory with images. (Legal advice says
that we need not add notices to each image file individually, if they
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
88 89 90 91
allow for that.). It is recommended to use the word "convert" to
describe the automatic process of changing an image from one format to
another (http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-02/msg00618.html).

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117

When installing a file with an "unusual" license (after checking first
it is ok), put a copy of the copyright and license in the file (if
possible. It's ok if this makes the file incompatible with its
original format, if it can still be used by Emacs), or in a README
file in the relevant directory.

The vast majority of files are copyright FSF and distributed under the
GPL. A few files (mainly related to language and charset support) are
copyright AIST alone, or both AIST and FSF. (Contact Kenichi Handa
with questions about legal issues in such files.) In all these cases,
the copyright years in each file should be updated each year.

There are some exceptions to the points in the previous paragraph, and
these are listed below for reference, together with any files where
the copyright needs to be updated in "unusual" ways.

If you find any other such cases, please consult to check they are ok,
and note them in this file. This includes missing copyright notices,
and "odd" copyright holders. In most cases, individual authors should
not appear in copyright statements. Either the copyright has been
assigned (check copyright.list) to the FSF (in which case the original
author should be removed and the year(s) transferred to the FSF); or
else it is possible the file should not be in Emacs at all (please
report!).

118
Note that it seems painfully clear that one cannot rely on commit logs,
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
119 120 121
or even ChangeLogs, for older changes. People often installed changes
from others, without recording the true authorship.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
122 123 124 125
[For reference, most of these points were established via email with
rms, 2007/1, "Copyright years".]


126 127
lisp/version.el           # emacs-copyright
lib-src/ebrowse.c         # version
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
128 129
lib-src/etags.c           # print_version
lib-src/rcs2log           # Copyright
130 131 132
Cocoa/Emacs.base/Contents/Info.plist
Cocoa/Emacs.base/Contents/Resources/English.lproj/InfoPlist.strings
GNUstep/Emacs.base/Resources/Info-gnustep.plist
133
   `set-copyright' in admin.el will do all the above.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
134

135 136 137 138 139 140
configure
 - copyright FSF, with unlimited permission to copy, distribute and modify

m4/getopt.m4
 - copyright FSF, with MIT-like license

141
install-sh
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
142 143
 - this file is copyright MIT, which is OK. Leave the copyright alone.

144
mkinstalldirs
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
145
src/m/news-r6.h
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
146 147
  public domain, leave alone.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
148 149 150
etc/refcards/*.tex
  also update the \def\year macro for the latest year.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
151 152 153
etc/BABYL, ms-kermit
  no notices (see below).

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
154
etc/emacs.csh
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
155 156
 - written by Michael DeCorte, who has no assignment. But trivial
 enough to not need license.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
157

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
158
etc/future-bug
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
159
 - doesn't need a humorless disclaimer, because Karl Fogel says we
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
160 161 162 163
 can consider it part of Emacs, and he has a blanker disclaimer for
 Emacs changes. (email to rgm "[Emacs-commit] emacs/etc future-bug",
 2007028)

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
164
etc/letter.pbm,letter.xpm
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
165
  - trivial, no notice needed.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
166 167
<http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-02/msg00324.html>

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
168 169 170
etc/FTP, ORDERS
  - trivial (at time of writing), no license needed

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
171 172 173 174 175 176 177
etc/GNU, INTERVIEW, LINUX-GNU, MOTIVATION, SERVICE, THE-GNU-PROJECT,
WHY-FREE
  rms: "These are statements of opinion or testimony. Their licenses
  should permit verbatim copying only. Please don't change the
  licenses that they have. They are distributed with Emacs but they
  are not part of Emacs."

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
178 179
etc/HELLO
  standard notices. Just a note that although the file itself is not
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
180
  really copyrightable, in the wider context of it being part of
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
181 182 183
  Emacs (and written by those with assignments), a standard notice is
  fine.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
184 185
etc/MAILINGLISTS
  rms: simple license is fine for this file
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
186

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
187 188 189
leim/CXTERM-DIC/4Corner.tit, ARRAY30.tit, CCDOSPY.tit, ECDICT.tit,
ETZY.tit, PY-b5.tit, Punct-b5.tit, Punct.tit, QJ-b5.tit, QJ.tit,
SW.tit, TONEPY.tit, ZOZY.tit
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
190 191 192
  - leave the copyrights alone.

leim/MISC-DIC/CTLau-b5.html, CTLau.html, cangjie-table.b5, cangjie-table.cns,
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
193
pinyin.map, ziranma.cin
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
194
  - leave the copyright alone.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
195 196
Note that pinyin.map, ziranma.cin (and hence the generated
leim/quail/PY.el, ZIRANMA.el) are under GPLv1 or later.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
197 198 199 200 201 202

leim/SKK-DIC/SKK-JISYO.L
ja-dic/ja-dic.el
  (the latter is auto-generated from the former). Leave the copyright alone.

lib-src/etags.c
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222
  Copyright information is duplicated in etc/ETAGS.README. Update that
  file too.

  Until 2007 etags.c was described as being copyright FSF and Ken Arnold.
  After some investigation in Feb 2007, then to the best of our
  knowledge we believe that the original 1984 Emacs version was based
  on the version in BSD4.2. See for example this 1985 post from Ken Arnold:
  <http://groups.google.com/group/mod.sources/browse_thread/thread/ffe5c55845a640a9>
    I have received enough requests for the current source to ctags
    to post it. Here is the latest version (what will go out with
    4.3, modulo any bugs fixed during the beta period). It is the
    4.2 ctags with recognition of yacc and lex tags added.

  See also a 1984 version of ctags (no copyright) posted to net.sources:
  <http://groups.google.com/group/net.sources/msg/a21b6c21be12a98d>
  Version of etags.c in emacs-16.56 duplicates comment typos.

  Accordingly, in Feb 2007 we added a 1984 copyright for the
  University of California and a revised BSD license. The terms of
  this require that the full license details be available in binary
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
223 224 225
  distributions - hence the file etc/ETAGS.README. The fact that the
  --version output just says "Copyright <year> FSF" is apparently OK
  from a legal point of view.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
226 227 228 229

lib-src/getopt1.c, getopt_int.h
  - these are from the GNU C library. Leave the copyrights alone.

230 231 232 233 234
lisp/cedet/semantic/imenu.el
  - See http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2010-03/msg00410.html
   in which Eric Ludlam established that the remaining contributions
   from authors other than himself were negligible.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
235 236 237 238 239 240
lisp/play/tetris.el
  - no special rules about the copyright. We note here that we believe
  (2007/1) there is no problem with our use of the name "tetris" or
  the concept.
  rms: "My understanding is that game rules as such are not copyrightable."
  <http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-01/msg00960.html>
241
  rms: Legal advice is that we are ok and need not worry about this.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
242

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
243 244 245 246

lisp/net/tramp.el
  - there are also copyrights in the body of the file. Update these too.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
247

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
248 249 250 251
lwlib/
rms (2007/02/17): "lwlib is not assigned to the FSF; we don't consider
it part of Emacs. [...] Therefore non-FSF copyrights are ok in lwlib."

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
252 253 254
NB don't change the GPL version used for lwlib .c and .h files (see
below).

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
255 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 280 281 282 283 284 285 286 287 288 289 290 291 292 293 294 295 296 297 298 299 300
FSF copyrights should only appear in files which have undergone
non-trivial cumulative changes from the original versions in the Lucid
Widget Library. NB this means that if you make non-trivial changes to
a file with no FSF copyright, you should add one. Also, if changes are
reverted to the extent that a file becomes basically the same as the
original version, the FSF copyright should be removed.

In my (rgm) opinion, as of Feb 2007, all the non-trivial files differ
significantly from the original versions, with the exception of
lwlib-Xm.h. Most of the changes that were made to this file have
subsequently been reverted. Therefore I removed the FSF copyright from
this file (which is arguably too trivial to merit a notice anyway). I
added FSF copyright to the following files which did not have them
already: Makefile.in, lwlib-Xaw.c, lwlib-int.h (borderline),
lwlib-utils.c (borderline), lwlib.c, lwlib.h.

Copyright years before the advent of public CVS in 2001 were those
when I judged (from the CVS logs) that non-trivial amounts of change
had taken place. I also adjusted the existing FSF years in xlwmenu.c,
xlwmenu.h, and xlwmenuP.h on the same basis.

Note that until Feb 2007, the following files in lwlib were lacking
notices: lwlib-int.h, lwlib.h, lwlib-Xaw.h, lwlib-Xlw.h, lwlib-utils.h

The following files did not list a Lucid copyright: xlwmenu.h,
xlwmenuP.h.

To the best of our knowledge, all the code files in lwlib were
originally part of the Lucid Widget Library, even if they did not say
so explicitly. For example, they were all present in Lucid Emacs 19.1
in 1992. The exceptions are the two Xaw files, which did not appear
till Lucid Emacs 19.9 in 1994. The file lwlib-Xaw.h is too trivial to
merit a copyright notice, but would presumably have the same one as
lwlib-Xaw.c. We have been unable to find a true standalone version of
LWL, if there was such a thing, to check definitively.

To clarify the situation, in Feb 2007 we added Lucid copyrights and
GPL notices to those files lacking either that were non-trivial,
namely: lwlib-int.h, lwlib.h, xlwmenu.h, xlwmenuP.h. This represents
our best understanding of the legal status of these files. We also
clarified the notices in Makefile.in, which was originally the
Makefile auto-generated from Lucid's Imakefile.

As of Feb 2007, the following files are considered too trivial for
notices: lwlib-Xaw.h, lwlib-Xlw.h, lwlib-utils.h.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
301 302 303 304 305 306 307 308 309 310 311 312 313 314 315
The version of lwlib/ first installed in Emacs seems to be the same as
that used in Lucid Emacs 19.8 (released 6-sep-93); except the two Xaw
files, which did not appear till Athena support was added in Lucid
Emacs 19.9. In Lucid Emacs 19.1, all files were under GPLv1 or later,
but by Lucid Emacs 19.8, lwlib.c and xlwmenu.c had been switched to v2
or later. These are the versions that were first installed in Emacs.
So in GNU Emacs, these two files have been under v2 or later since
1994.

It seems that it was the intention of Lucid to use v1 or later
(excepting the two files mentioned previously); so this is the license
we have used when adding notices to code that did not have notices
originally. Although we have the legal right to switch to v2 or later,
rms prefers that we do not do so.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
316

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
317 318 319 320 321 322 323
doc/*/doclicense.texi
  - leave the copyright alone in this imported file.

doc/*/*.texi - All manuals should be under GFDL (but see below), and
should include a copy of it, so that they can be distributed
separately. faq.texi has a different license, for some reason no-one
can remember.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
324 325 326
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-04/msg00583.html
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-04/msg00618.html

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
327 328 329 330 331
doc/misc/mh-e.texi is dual-licensed (GPL and GFDL) per agreement with
FSF (reconfirmed by rms Aug 25 2008).  Discussion with
licensing@fsf.org starting on Thu, 07 Aug 2003 with subject:
"[gnu.org #58812] Changing license of MH-E manual"

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
332

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
333 334 335 336
msdos/is_exec.c, sigaction.c - these files are copyright DJ Delorie.
Leave the copyrights alone. Leave the Eli Zaretskii copyright in
is_exec.c alone. See the msdos/README file for the legal history of
these files.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
337

338 339 340
msdos/sed*.inp - These files are copyright FSF and distributed under
an MIT-like license.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 349 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 368 369 370 371 372 373 374 375 376 377 378 379 380 381 382 383 384 385 386 387 388 389

oldXMenu/
  Keep the "copyright.h" method used by X11, rather than moving the
  licenses into the files. Note that the original X10.h did not use
  copyright.h, but had an explicit notice, which we retain.

If you make non-trivial changes to a file which does not have an FSF
notice, add one and a GPL notice (as per Activate.c). If changes to a
file are reverted such that it becomes essentially the same as the
original X11 version, remove the FSF notice and GPL.

Only the files which differ significantly from the original X11
versions should have FSF copyright and GPL notices. At time of writing
(Feb 2007), this is: Activate.c, Create.c, Internal.c. I (rgm)
established this by diff'ing the current files against those in X11R1,
and when I found significant differences looking in the ChangeLog for
the years they originated (the CVS logs are truncated before 1999). I
therefore removed the FSF notices (added in 200x) from the other
files. There are some borderline cases IMO: AddSel.c, InsSel.c,
XMakeAssoc.c, XMenu.h. For these I erred on the side of NOT adding FSF
notices.

With regards to whether the files we have changed should have GPL
added or not, rms says (2007-02-25, "oldXmenu issues"):

    It does not make much difference, because oldXmenu is obsolete
    except for use in Emacs (and it is not normally used in Emacs any
    more either).

    So, to make things simple, please put our changes under the GPL.

insque.c had no copyright notice until 2005. The version of insque.c
added to Emacs 1992-01-27 is essentially the same as insremque.c added
to glic three days later by Roland McGrath, with an FSF copyright and
GPL, but no ChangeLog entry:
<http://sources.redhat.com/cgi-bin/cvsweb.cgi/~checkout~/libc/misc/insremque.c?\
rev=1.1&cvsroot=glibc>
To the best of his recollection, McGrath (who has a copyright
assignment) was the author of this file (email from roland at frob.com
to rms, 2007-02-23, "Where did insque.c come from?"). The FSF
copyright and GPL in this file are therefore correct as far as we
understand it.

Imakefile had no legal info in Feb 2007, but was obviously based on
the X11 version (which also had no explicit legal info). As it was
unused, I removed it. It would have the same MIT copyright as
Makefile.in does now.


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
390
src/gmalloc.c
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
391 392
  - contains numerous copyrights from the GNU C library. Leave them alone.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
393
src/acldef.h, chpdef.h, ndir.h
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
394 395 396
  - see comments below. These files are OK to be released with Emacs
  22, but we may want to revisit them afterwards.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
397

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
398 399
** Some notes on resolved issues, for historical information only

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
400 401 402
etc/TERMS
rms: "surely written either by me or by ESR. (If you can figure out
which year, I can probably tell you which.) Either way, we have papers
403 404
for it." It was present in Emacs-16.56 (15-jul-85). rms: "Then I
conclude it was written by me."
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414

etc/ulimit.hack
  Very obsolete file removed March 2007. Doesn't say who the author
is, but web-search suggests Karl Kleinpaste, who has no Emacs
assignment. Trivial anyway.
http://groups.google.com/group/comp.unix.shell/browse_thread/thread/bf3df496994\
9f1df/7e5922c67b3a98fb
http://groups.google.com/group/comp.unix.questions/msg/cc7e49cacfd1ccb4
    (original 1987 source)

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426
lisp/term/README
  - had no copyright notice till Feb 2007. ChangeLog.3 suggests it was
  written by Eric Raymond. When asked by rms on 14 Feb 2007 he said:

    I don't remember writing it, but it reads like my prose and I believe
    I wrote the feature(s) it's describing.  So I would have been the
    likeliest person to write it.

    Odds are that I did, but I'm not certain.

  Accordingly, FSF copyright was added.

427
src/unexhp9k800.c
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
428
  http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-02/msg00138.html
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
429 430 431 432 433
  - briefly removed due to legal uncertainly Jan-Mar 2007. The
  relevant assignment is under "hp9k800" in copyright.list. File was
  written by John V. Morris at HP, and disclaimed by the author and
  HP. So this file is public domain.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
434

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
435 436 437 438 439 440 441 442 443 444
K Rodgers changes
 It was pointed out that K Rodgers only had assigments for VC and
 ps-print, but had changed several other files. We tried to contact
 him for a general assignment, but he proved uncommunicative (despite
 initially indicating to rms he would sign an assignment). As a result, his
 changes were removed and/or rewritten independently. For details, see
 threads:
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-04/msg00225.html
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-04/msg00257.html

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
445 446 447
 But then an assignment arrived before the release of Emacs 22:
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-04/msg01427.html

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
448

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
449 450 451 452 453 454 455 456
lisp/progmodes/python.el
Dave Love alerted us to a potential legal problem:
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-pretest-bug/2007-04/msg00459.html

On consultation with a lawyer, we found there was no problem:
http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-05/msg00466.html


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
457 458 459 460
** Issues that are "fixed" for the release of Emacs 22, but we may
   wish to revisit later in more detail


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
461 462 463
admin/check-doc-strings
  File says it's in the public domain, but that might not make it so.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
464 465
etc/BABYL
  File written long ago by authors with no assignment. Keep them
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
466 467
  without notices for now, try and contact authors if possible. Be
  ready to remove these files if the authors ever object.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
468

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
469
etc/ms-kermit
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
470
etc/e/eterm-color.ti
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
471 472
src/acldef.h, chpdef.h, ndir.h
  On legal advice from Matt Norwood, the following comment was added
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
473
  to these files in Feb/Mar 2007:
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
474 475 476 477 478 479 480 481 482 483

    The code here is forced by the interface, and is not subject to
    copyright, constituting the only possible expression of the
    algorithm in this format.

  With the addition of this notice, these files are OK for the
  upcoming Emacs-22 release. Post-release, we can revisit this issue
  and possibly add a list of all authors who have changed these files.
  (details in email from Matt Norwood to rms, 2007/02/03).

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
484 485 486 487 488 489 490 491 492 493 494
etc/ms-7bkermit
  Says it was written by Andy Lowry and Joel Spolsky. No entry for
either in copyright.list. NB this file is not "constrained" like
ms-kermit (rms: "We know it isn't. A comment at the front says it has
other bindings which might be handy."). File removed March 2007.
Re-add if clear up status at some point.

etc/Xkeymap.txt
  No info on author. File removed March 2007. rms: "It says it is
RLK's way of remapping his keyboard, so it is not constrained. I think
it was written by RLK. Let's delete it; if we contact RLK again, we
495
can put it back." Actually, RLK == Robert Krawitz has an Emacs
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
496 497 498
assignment. So this could be restored if it is still useful, but Jan Djärv
says it is obsolete:
<http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-03/msg00673.html>
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
499 500 501

src/m/mips4.h, news-risc.h, pmax.h
src/s/aix3-2.h, bsd386.h, hpux8.h, hpux9.h, irix4-0.h, irix5-0.h,
502
netbsd.h, sol2-3.h, usg5-4-2.h
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 511 512 513 514 515 516 517 518 519 520 521 522 523 524 525 526 527 528 529 530 531 532 533 534 535 536 537 538 539 540 541 542 543 544
  - all these (not obviously trivial) files were missing copyrights
  till Feb 2007, when FSF copyright was added. Matt Norwood advised:

    For now, I think the best policy is to assume that we do have
    assignments from the authors (I recall many of these header files
    as having been originally written by rms), and to attach an FSF
    copyright with GPL notice. We can amend this if and when we
    complete the code audit. Any additions to these files by
    non-assigned authors are arguably "de minimis" contributions to
    Emacs: small changes or suggestions to a work that are subsumed in
    the main authors' copyright in the entire work.

Here is my (rgm) take on the details of the above files:

mips4.h
  might be trivial? started trivial, been added to in tiny changes by
  those with FSF assignment, often result of email suggestions by others.

news-risc.h
  started trivial. Grown by tiny additions, plus chunk
  from mips.h, which was and is Copyright FSF

pmax.h
  started trivial. grown in tiny changes, except for maybe Jim Wilson's
  comment.

? irix4-0.h
  I would say started non-trivial (1992, rms). only tiny changes since
  installed.

? irix5-0.h
  I would say started non-trivial (1993, jimb, heavily based
  on irix4-0.h). A few borderline non-tiny changes since.

usg5-4-2.h
 started non-trivial, but was heavily based on usg5-4.h, which was and is
 copyright FSF. only tiny changes since installed.

sol2-3.h
 started trivial. only non-tiny change (1994) incorporated code from
 usg5-4.h, which was and is copyright FSF.

545
aix3-2.h, bsd386.h, hpux8.h, hpux9.h, netbsd.h
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
546 547
  started trivial, grown in tiny changes.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
548 549 550 551 552
netbsd.h:
Roland McGrath said to rms (2007/02/17): "I don't really remember
anything about it. If I put it in without other comment, then probably
I wrote it myself."

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
553

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
554 555 556 557 558 559
Someone might want to tweak the copyright years (for dates before
2001) that I used in all these files.

Note: erring on the side of caution, I also added notices to some
files I thought might be considered non-trivial (if one includes
comment) in s/:
560 561
  aix4-1.h hpux10.h irix6-0.h irix6-5.h
  ptx4.h sol2.h 
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
562 563 564 565 566

(everything with > 30 non-blank lines, which at least is _some_ kind of
system)


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
567 568 569
*** These are copyright issues that need not be fixed until after
    Emacs 22 is released (though if they can be fixed before, that is
    obviously good):
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
570 571


572
Is it OK to just `bzr remove' a file for legal reasons, or is
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
573
something more drastic needed? A removed file is still available from
574 575
the repository, if suitable options are applied. (This issue obviously
does not affect a release).
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
576
  rms: will ask lawyer
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
577 578


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
579 580 581 582
Make sure that all files with non-standard copyrights or licenses are
noted in this file.


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
583 584
REMOVED etc/gnu.xpm, nt/icons/emacs21.ico, nt/icons/sink.ico
  - Restore if find legal info. emacs21.ico is not due to Davenport.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
585 586
  Geoff Voelker checked but could not find a record of where it came
  from.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
587

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
588

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
589 590 591 592
etc/images
  Image files from GTK, Gnome are under GPLv2 (no "or later"?). RMS will
  contact image authors in regards to future switch to v3.

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
593

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
594 595 596 597 598 599 600 601 602 603 604
etc/TUTORIAL* (translations)
  switch to GPL (see english TUTORIAL)
  rms: "We can leave the TUTORIAL translations alone until their
  maintainers update them."
  Can adapt short license text from end of GPL translations at:
  http://www.gnu.org/licenses/translations.html
  Only a few sentences around the license notice need changing from
  previous version.
Done: TUTORIAL.eo


Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
605 606
*** These are copyright issues still to be addressed:

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
607 608 609
None known.


610 611 612 613 614 615 616
** NOTES ON RELICENSING TO GPL3

The EMACS_22_BASE branch was changed to GPLv3 (or later) 2007/07/25.

Some notes:
(see http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2007-07/msg01431.html)

617
1. There are some files in the Emacs tree which are not part of Emacs (eg
618 619 620 621 622
those included from Gnulib). These are all copyright FSF and (at time
of writing) GPL >= 2. rms says may as well leave the licenses of these
alone (may import them from Gnulib again). These are:

    Gnulib:
623
    move-if-change
624 625 626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635
    src/getloadavg.c
    src/gmalloc.c
    src/md5.c
    src/md5.h
    src/mktime.c
    src/strftime.c
    src/termcap.c
    src/tparam.c

    Others:
    config.guess
    config.sub
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
636
    doc/man/texinfo.tex
637 638 639 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 648 649 650 651 652 653 654 655 656 657 658 659 660 661 662 663 664 665 666 667 668 669 670 671 672 673

Note _not_ included in the above are src/regex.{c,h} (rms: "That
forked version is only in Emacs, so definitely relicense that."), and
oldXMenu/insque.c (rms: "We wrote that specifically for Emacs, so
definitely relicense that.").

2. The files that are copyright FSF and AIST, or AIST alone, should be
and were updated, ditto the oldXMenu files with FSF copyright, and
msdos/is_exec.c and sigaction.c.

3. lwlib/

Files originally in Lucid Widget Library were left alone (excludes
ChangeLog, etc), ie remain under GPL v1 or later, or v2 or later.
(rms: "We may as well leave this alone, since we are never going to
change it much.")

4. There are some files where the FSF holds no copyright. These were
left alone:

   leim/MISC-DIC/CTLau-b5.html  >= v2
   leim/MISC-DIC/CTLau.html     >= v2
     (above included in lisp/international/titdic-cnv.el)
   leim/MISC-DIC/pinyin.map     >= v1
   leim/MISC-DIC/ziranma.cin    >= v1
   leim/SKK-DIC/SKK-JISYO.L     >= v2
   leim/SKK-DIC/README          >= v2
   leim/ja-dic/ja-dic.el        >= v2

5. At time of writing, some non-Emacs icons included from Gnome remain
under GPLv2 (no "or later"). See:

   etc/images/gnus/README
   etc/images/mail/README
   etc/images/README
   nt/icons/README

Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
674 675 676

This file is part of GNU Emacs.

677
GNU Emacs is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
678
it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
679 680
the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or
(at your option) any later version.
Glenn Morris's avatar
Glenn Morris committed
681 682 683 684 685 686 687

GNU Emacs is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
GNU General Public License for more details.

You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
688
along with GNU Emacs.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.